Insulated vs. Non-Insulated Garage Doors:

Non-insulated doors are the lowest-cost option for garage door installation but perform poorly in Western NY winters. They allow cold air to enter the garage, making it harder to heat the rooms above or beside the garage. Additionally, they allow more noise and tend to dent easily, which can lead to increased garage door maintenance needs.

Polystyrene insulated doors are a step up in terms of performance. They provide better temperature control, making the door feel tighter and more solid. Most mid-range homeowners choose this option for their garage door installation.

Polyurethane insulated doors are the most energy-efficient choice for garage door repair needs. Foam is injected into the panels, creating a solid core that improves strength and increases R-value (thermal resistance). In Rochester, where temperatures can swing from near-zero to 90°F, this stability is especially beneficial. A polyurethane door reduces drafts, prevents heat loss, and even increases the lifespan of your opener by reducing strain, which is essential for long-term garage door maintenance.

A unique local issue is wind pressure from lake-effect storms. Insulated doors handle wind better because they are stronger and more rigid. If your home faces strong winds, we highly recommend insulated steel doors for optimal performance.

Another overlooked benefit is noise reduction. If your garage is close to a bedroom or living area, insulated doors make a significant difference. Customers often report a 40–60% reduction in noise, which can enhance your living experience.

Finally, insulation helps prevent panel warping. In Rochester’s humidity, non-insulated doors can bend or flex over time. Insulated doors stay straighter and last longer, reducing the need for frequent garage door repair.